Insurance Cold Calling Scripts That Actually Convert in 2026
The best insurance cold calling scripts aren't scripts at all—they're flexible frameworks that guide the conversation while leaving room for genuine human connection. This guide provides battle-tested script templates for every major insurance line, complete with compliance disclosures, objection handling, and closing techniques that work in today's market.
Why Scripts Should Be Frameworks, Not Rigid Scripts
The word "script" carries a negative connotation in the insurance industry, and for good reason. Consumers can immediately tell when an agent is reading robotically from a piece of paper. They disengage. They hang up. They feel like a number rather than a person. And yet, the agents who consistently convert at the highest rates all follow some form of structured conversation framework.
The difference between a rigid script and an effective framework is flexibility. A rigid script dictates exactly what to say word-for-word, regardless of what the prospect says. A framework provides a roadmap—it tells you what ground to cover and in what order, but it lets you use your own words and adapt to the prospect's responses in real time.
Think of it like GPS navigation. The GPS gives you the route, but you're the one driving. If there's traffic (an objection), you can take a detour (an alternative approach) and still arrive at your destination (a qualified appointment or sale). The frameworks below are designed exactly this way—they give you structure without sacrificing authenticity.
Pro Tip: Use AI Coaching to Improve Your Delivery
Having a great script framework is only half the equation—delivery matters just as much. Real-time agent coaching tools can analyze your tone, pacing, and talk-to-listen ratio during live calls, helping you refine your delivery with every conversation.
Script Fundamentals: Every Call Should Include These Elements
Regardless of which insurance line you're selling, every outbound call should follow the same fundamental structure. Master these elements and you'll have a solid foundation for any script:
- Compliance disclosure – State who you are, that you're a licensed agent, and the purpose of the call within the first 30 seconds
- Permission check – Ask if now is a good time to talk (this also reinforces consent documentation)
- Rapport building – Find a genuine connection point before diving into business
- Needs discovery – Ask open-ended questions to understand the prospect's situation
- Value presentation – Connect your solution to their specific needs
- Objection handling – Address concerns without being pushy
- Clear next step – Set an appointment, schedule a follow-up, or begin the application
Script 1: Medicare Advantage Cold Call
Critical Compliance Note
You cannot cold call Medicare beneficiaries for sales purposes without documented Permission to Contact (PTC). This script assumes you have PTC and, if during AEP/OEP, a valid Scope of Appointment. Unsolicited Medicare sales calls violate CMS marketing guidelines and can result in sanctions.
Opening
Needs Discovery Questions
"Are you currently enrolled in Original Medicare, a Medicare Advantage plan, or a Medicare Supplement plan?"
"How satisfied are you with your current coverage, on a scale of 1 to 10?"
"Are there any specific areas where you feel your current plan falls short—like prescription drug costs, specialist access, or out-of-pocket expenses?"
"Do you have a preferred doctor or hospital that's important for you to keep access to?"
Transition to Value
Key principles: Never pressure a Medicare beneficiary. Never make guarantees about benefits without knowing their specific zip code, eligibility, and plan availability. Always confirm that you're only discussing the products listed on the SOA. If they bring up a product not on the SOA, schedule a separate appointment with a new SOA.
Script 2: Life Insurance Cold Call
Opening
Needs Discovery
"Do you currently have any life insurance coverage in place—through work or individually?"
"And who would depend on your income if something were to happen to you? A spouse, children?"
"Have you thought about how much coverage you might need, or is that something you'd like help figuring out?"
Transition and Close
Key principles: Life insurance is emotional. The prospect is thinking about their mortality and their family's financial security. Be empathetic and patient. Don't rush through the health questions. And always frame the coverage in terms of what it protects—their family's home, their children's education, their spouse's retirement—not in terms of a death benefit dollar amount.
Script 3: Final Expense Insurance Cold Call
Opening
Building Rapport and Needs Discovery
"A lot of the folks I talk to are concerned about two things—not being a burden on their family, and making sure their wishes are respected. Is that something that resonates with you?"
"Do you currently have any life insurance at all? Some people have a small policy from years ago and aren't sure if it's still active."
"And is this something you've set a budget for, or are you wondering what it might cost?"
Transition and Close
Key principles: Final expense prospects are often older adults on fixed incomes. Speak slowly and clearly. Be patient if they need to repeat information. Never use high-pressure tactics—these prospects are particularly vulnerable and regulators watch final expense marketing closely. The "state-regulated program" framing works because it positions the product as something legitimate and supervised, which builds trust.
Script 4: ACA Health Insurance Cold Call
Opening
Needs Discovery
"Are you currently covered under any health insurance plan right now?"
"Is this coverage for just yourself, or would you need to include a spouse or dependents?"
"And what's most important to you in a health plan—keeping your premiums low, having low out-of-pocket costs when you see a doctor, or keeping access to specific doctors?"
"Do you take any regular medications that we should make sure are covered?"
"And roughly what's your annual household income? I ask because many people qualify for subsidies that can significantly lower their monthly premium—sometimes to under $50 a month."
Transition and Close
Key principles: ACA prospects are often price-sensitive and may not understand how subsidies work. Leading with the subsidy angle gets attention. Always emphasize that your services are free to the consumer. Use language like "let's see what you qualify for" rather than "let me sell you a plan." If the prospect doesn't qualify for a Special Enrollment Period, document the reason and set a reminder for Open Enrollment.
Script 5: Health Insurance for Small Business
Opening
Needs Discovery
"When does your current plan renew? Have you seen your renewal rates yet?"
"What was your rate increase last year? A lot of businesses are seeing 8–15% increases and it's squeezing their margins."
"Are you working with a broker currently, or managing this yourself?"
Transition and Close
Objection Handling: The Top 5 Insurance Objections
No script is complete without preparation for the most common objections. Here are the five objections you'll hear most often and frameworks for handling each one:
1. "I'm not interested."
2. "I already have coverage."
3. "I can't afford it."
4. "Send me some information."
5. "I need to think about it."
Compliance Disclosures: What You Must Say on Every Call
Compliance is not separate from your script—it's embedded in it. Every outbound insurance call requires certain disclosures, and failing to include them is both a legal violation and a missed opportunity to build trust. Here's what you need to cover:
- Identify yourself and your agency – Your name and the name of the agency you represent
- State that you are a licensed insurance agent – This is required in most states and builds credibility
- Recording disclosure – If the call is recorded, disclose this at the start of the conversation
- Purpose of the call – Clearly state why you're calling (telemarketing disclosure)
- Medicare-specific disclosures – For Medicare calls, additional CMS disclosures are required including "Medicare has neither reviewed nor endorsed this information"
- Opt-out provision – Inform the consumer that they can request not to be called again
Never Skip Disclosures to Save Time
Some agents skip or rush through compliance disclosures because they feel it slows down the call. This is a critical mistake. Beyond the legal risk, disclosures actually help your conversion rate—they establish professionalism and build trust from the first seconds of the call. Consumers are more likely to engage with someone who sounds legitimate and transparent.
Tips for Better Cold Call Performance
Having the right script framework is essential, but execution determines results. Here are evidence-based tips for maximizing your cold call conversion rates:
Tone and Pacing
- Mirror the prospect's energy level. If they're upbeat, match that energy. If they're reserved, dial it back. Mismatched energy creates subconscious discomfort.
- Speak at 150–170 words per minute. This is the ideal range for comprehension and trust-building. Most nervous agents speak at 200+ WPM, which sounds rushed and untrustworthy.
- Use strategic pauses. After asking a question, pause and let the prospect fill the silence. After making a key point, pause to let it sink in. Silence is your most underused tool.
- Smile when you talk. It sounds cliché, but smiling physically changes your vocal tone in ways that are detectable over the phone. Prospects can "hear" a smile.
Personalization
- Use their name naturally. Say their name 2–3 times during the call—at the opening, during a key transition, and at the close. More than that sounds manipulative.
- Reference their specific situation. If you know they came from a specific lead source, mention it: "I see you were looking at health plans on [website]."
- Tailor your value proposition. Don't present the same benefits to everyone. If they mentioned cost, lead with affordability. If they mentioned access to doctors, lead with network breadth.
Call Timing
- Speed-to-lead matters: Calling a web lead within 5 minutes of submission increases contact rates by 400% compared to waiting an hour
- Best days: Wednesday and Thursday are consistently the highest-converting days for insurance cold calls
- Best times: 10:00–11:30 AM and 1:30–3:00 PM in the prospect's local time tend to yield the highest answer rates
- Follow-up cadence: Don't give up after one attempt. It takes an average of 6–8 attempts to reach a lead. Space your attempts across different times and days.
Level Up with AI Coaching
Want to know exactly where your calls are losing momentum? AI coaching for sales calls analyzes every conversation and provides specific, actionable feedback on your opener effectiveness, question quality, objection handling, and closing technique—so every call is better than the last.
Putting It All Together
The scripts in this guide are frameworks, not crutches. Use them as starting points and adapt them to your natural communication style, your specific market, and the unique needs of each prospect. The best agents internalize the structure—the flow from disclosure to rapport to discovery to value to close—and then deliver it in a way that feels like a natural conversation rather than a sales pitch.
Practice these frameworks until the structure becomes second nature. Record yourself and listen back. Review your calls with your supervisor or with AI coaching tools. Track which openers get the best engagement, which questions uncover the most useful information, and which closing approaches yield the highest appointment-setting rates. Then iterate. The best cold callers in insurance are not born—they are made through deliberate practice and continuous improvement.
Convert More Calls with AI-Powered Coaching
AgentTech Dialer analyzes every call in real time, coaching your agents on script adherence, tone, pacing, and objection handling—so every rep performs like your best rep.
Try AgentTech Dialer Now